With many countries scaling up their production, storage and distribution of biofuels in order to meet growing energy security challenges, it has become increasingly clear that the order of implementation matters as much as its speed.
Being able to produce vast amounts of biofuel is counterproductive if the storage infrastructure and relief valves are not in place to ensure it can be produced and stored at scale, and biofuel supplies that the majority of vehicle owners cannot use are similarly useless.
This has become a particular flashpoint in countries such as Indonesia, which enacted an ambitious B50 (50 per cent biodiesel) blend policy, increasing from B30 in only four years.
For comparison, the UK only has a ten per cent biofuel blend in its petrol, so what can you do to rapidly scale up production?
Ultimately, it is less about how quickly you move but the order in which you make decisions, the dependencies every part of the supply chain has and deciding when it is appropriate to travel faster than the market is currently moving.
Why Does Biofuel Adoption Need To Be Gradual?
The speed at which countries such as India, Indonesia, Malaysia and Vietnam are introducing or expanding their biofuel policies is understandable given geopolitical uncertainty with regard to access to oil, petrol and diesel, but it is limited by the ability of the country as a whole to adopt.
Biofuels are carefully engineered to be as close as possible to existing fuels, but the greater the concentration of biofuels, the more the fuel management system, engine and ancillaries need to be adjusted to take the slight differences into account.
Older cars, for example, use certain materials for their seals that wear out quickly when exposed to ethanol, and there is a potential efficiency loss when using biofuel in an engine not adapted for it.
Many cars can be converted to run on biofuel, but drivers need to be made aware of the changes and be given support to make these changes so that there is no major disruption that emerges as a consequence.
This leads to a complex balancing act; moving too slowly risks your energy security, but moving too quickly can be overly disruptive and risks productivity in other ways.
Policies need to have timescales that ensure that biofuel can be produced in time and at the levels required, can be properly stored safely, and that there are enough distribution centres to ensure that motorists will not run out.
The solution is to find the right speed and the right order to make upgrades.
Why Does Sequencing Matter In Biofuel Infrastructure Production?
This is what makes sequencing so important in biofuel implementation, perhaps more so than in other aspects of infrastructure. Certain implementation projects can only be completed when other work they are dependent on has also been completed.
At a basic level, there are five main issues surrounding biofuel distribution, each of which has its own implications and dependencies:
- Harvesting – At present, the most popular feedstock for biofuel is reliant on arable land and resources typically needed for food production.
- Refining – Increasing biofuel supplies relies on ensuring adequate capacity to efficiently refine feedstock into biofuel products.
- Transportation And Storage – Biofuels need to be stored in ways that ensure that they remain safe and not under too much pressure, something achieved through automatic venting.
- Distribution – Aside from transportation, petrol stations need to be properly equipped to stock, supply and sell biofuel.
- Compatibility – Ensuring that the vast majority of cars can run on the legally required biofuel blends or ensuring that conversion kits are made available if not.
All of these stages are reliant on each other in various ways, which can make the sequencing of scaling up biofuel production complex.
How Do Dependencies Affect The Scale Of Biofuel Implementation
There are several ways to sequence biofuel implementation, but the most common way is to take a “dependency-first” approach: upgrade every step that can be done without relying on another stage of the process, wait for them to catch up and upgrade further.
For example, increasing storage capacity can be done by designing adequate storage tanks, fitting the right valves and vents on them in order to ensure they are safe and scaling up this production in line with the output of biofuel refiners and transportation needs.
Scaling up more quickly means identifying when dependencies become bottlenecks, how long they would take to fix and working proactively to minimise the problems that they cause.
This means scaling up storage so refineries can output more efficiently or making cars which can use higher concentrations of biofuel more widely available.